The following is a reposting of an article I did on August 20th, talking about how banks should stop giving away your log-in details by requiring you to type vs. swipe.  (in this particular case, Citi could save $88 bucks by giving away our PCI 2.x Certified persona magnetic card/PIN Entry Device) vs. giving away $100 bucks.  

HomeATM's Weapon of "Phish Destruction"...

There a lot of banking promotions cropping up designed to "lure" customers over.



Want to lure them over? Use phishing. Did I just say "use phishing" to lure them over? I did.



$100 isn't going to do it. When it comes to innovative marketing ideas, bribing a customer has never been near the top of the list. But...instead of customers being lured away from your bank by becoming a victim of phishing, "lure" them to your bank by using "phishing" as bait. It'll work hook, line and sinker.



Here's what I'm thinking. How about running an innovative promotion in which a bank guarantees their customer is 100% protected from phishing. If you lure them by protecting them from the bad guys (which would also protect the $1000's, not $100, of dollars in their bank account), you would attract more customers than $100 would attract AND, at the same time, enhance your bank's image. It's all about security. Here's proof:


HALF (49%) Would Consider Changing Banks Following Card Fraud...22% "Would" Change Banks!

Editors Note: Wow, if I was a financial institution offering "online banking"that headline would haunt me 24 hours a day until I figured out a wayto either change it or use it to create an opportunity for my onlinebank to flourish.



My first thought would be: "If 50% would consider "changing banks AFTER" they get hit by card fraud/onlinebanking/phishing fraud, how many would consider "changing banks" to"AVOID" getting hit?



And to which competitor would they go?



I'd conclude that if they "left because of insecurity" they would probably "come on board BECAUSE of security."



Soif I wanted to open a portal for dissatisfied online banking customers,I would use a uniquely positioned product to ensure my customerssecurity. I'm thinking Swipe vs. Type here. Then I would think...howmany potential customers could my bank procure by "guaranteeing" onlinesecurity? Research would determine if it was millions or only"Hundreds of Thousands." I think I made my point. If not, I challenge you to continue reading...



Banks have a "serious issue" with phishing and I am suggesting that there is a low-cost solution to completely eliminating this on-going threat.

Eliminate typing and you'll eliminate phishing. First a quick backgrounder...



The nature of this beast known as "phishing" is to lure these onlinebanking folks, with a sophisticated and genuine looking trap whichincludes genuine looking emails which provide links to genuine lookingsites. (a new "type" of bait and switch)





Once there, users are simply instructed to do what they've been programmed to do since day one with online banking. And therein lies the problem...
They are told to "type" in their username and password to log-in.



Problem is, once they "type" in their "username | password" they provide full access to their accounts to the phisheries.





Ifyou haven't figured it out already, (something phishy goin' on here) allow me to point out the majorflaw in this process...





If online banking customers had not beenoriginally programmed to "type" anything into a box the first place, then this type of phishing would not have cropped up in the second place. A simple case of "cause and effect."





Case in point: Imagine if you will, that when ATM's first came out, users were instructed to "make up" a username and password for whichwould have provided full access to ATM's? How smart would that havebeen?



Fortunately the banks were smarter than that and they required that their ATM customers insert their card into a built-in card reader AND enter their PIN. Two factor authentication 101. What you "have" (card) and what you "know" (PIN)



Why should it be any different for online banking log-in?



What has happened since then to make them believe "typing" is safer than "swiping?" Why are they suddenly dissin' the card?





Window of Opportunity



Instead of dissin' the card, I say "DISCARD" the antiquated username and password log-in process and instruct customers "USE THEIR CARD" (what they have) and their PIN (what they know) thereby replicatingthe exact same process these customers use gain access to an ATM.



True2FA. The only difference would be that authentication would be done inthe safety (no skimmers/no cameras) of the online banking customers own home...with a PCI 2.x certified (not compliant..."certified") personal PIN Entry Device. (providing 2FA 3DES E2EE DUKPT Security)



If the online banking community introduced their customers to a simple(not) new log-in process, one whereby they require that theironline banking customers log-in the "same way" they do at ATM's...by "swiping" with "THEIR CARD, and securely entering "THEIR PIN" they would greatlyenhance the security of their online banking sites.





This two factor secure log-in would eliminate the issues they arehaving with these phishing attacks altogether. A secure 2FA 3DES E2EE DUKPT log-in would also eliminate threats created by cloned bank websites, cloned cards, DNS Hijacking,etc. The data is never in the clear...so when it comes to becoming a victim of fraud, your customer is in the clear.



In effect, banks would be arming their online banking customers with aweapon of phish destruction, one that fights cybercrime and "empowers"them as mini-profit centers. Does anyone disagree with the statementthat "Bill Payments, Money Transfers, and secure online transactions"ALL make money for banks? (again, see previous post)






That said, I humbly suggest it's high time to "studythree key issues" more closely.



Let's look at "these issues" one at a time:




  • Bank "ISSUES" the Card,

  • Bank "ISSUES" the PIN,

  • Banks ISSUES a $12 PCI 2.x Certified 2FA 3DES E2EE DUKPT Secure Card/PIN Reader



$12! Yes (in quantity)...banks could save $88 per customer (compared to Citi's offer above) and PROTECT their customer. Protect them from what? Did you know that the average phishing attack costs the bank and thebank customer $350. Want proof?



Okay, here it is from Gartner Research:



According to research firm,Gartner, banks, online payment organizations and other financialinstitutions are bearing most of the financial cost of phishingattacks.



(A survey of nearly 4,000 US consumers revealed a 40% increase in the number of phishing victims in 2008 over the year before to five million.)
The average loss was $352 per phishing attack, but consumers said they had recovered 56% of their losses from the financial institutions involved. (sounds like the $100 bribe above is lost in the first phishing attack to me)



"The findings underline the fact that the war against phishing is far from over," said Avivah Litan, analyst at Gartner.
(Yes, the very same Avivah Litan who says "never" enter your PIN on the Internet unless it's hardware based)



Want to read more on this subject?...click here.













Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Posted by John B. Frank Tuesday, September 1, 2009 0 comments

For your amusement:



Posted by John B. Frank 0 comments



Excerpt from USA Today:  As more consumers whip out debit cards, issuers are rolling out new rewards programs and enhancing old ones in hopes of boosting card spending.  (Editor's Note:  Of course the banks are going to roll out rewards programs for signature debit.  These banks earn tons of cash ($38 Billion last year alone) on signature debit overdraft charges as well as significantly more on signature debit's Interchange Fee which is much higher than PIN Debit because it's up to 15 times more insecure.  Next time you hear someone say there needs to be a balance between convenience and security, tell them they're nuts...or at least ask them "why do you keep saying that?"  Where's the balance between security and convenience at airport security?  Do we mind?  No.  Why?  Because it keeps us safe.  There's numbers in safety...



Debit card transactions have grown rapidly in recent years, but the recession has accelerated the trend. In the fourth quarter of 2008, U.S. debit spending exceeded credit card spending for the first time, says Visa. That continued in the first quarter of 2009 with $202 billion in debit card purchases and $176 billion on credit cards.



Brian Riley, a research director at TowerGroup, a research firm, believes that debit card use will continue to grow as the economy recovers. Debit cards provide a convenient way for consumers to pay for their purchases, he says. Banks are also making it more rewarding for consumers to use their (signature) debit cards in hopes of boosting profits. When consumers use (signature) debit cards, merchants have to pay banks up to 2.1% to process the transaction, says The Nilson Report.



 

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Posted by John B. Frank 0 comments



Gartner States that Online Banking is "Dangerous" in newest analysis:



Event
On 24 August 2009, the Washington Post's Security Fix blog reported that the Financial Services Information Sharing and Analysis Center (FS ISAC) — an industry group created by a U.S. presidential order to share data about critical threats to the financial sector — had issued a confidential alert to its members, which include the Federal Reserve, the New York Stock Exchange, Citigroup, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs. The FS ISAC alert urged business bank customers to "carry out all online banking activity from a stand-alone, hardened, and locked-down computer from which e-mail and Web browsing is not possible."



Editor's Note:  Why dedicate a stand-alone, hardened and locked-down computer from which e-mail and Web browsing is not possible, when it would be safer, more cost-effective and more useful to utilize a PCI 2.x Certified "stand-alone" device which not only provides multi-factor authentication, but also provides "real-time" money transfer, B2B payments and more? 



The FS ISAC issued its alert in response to reports from financial institutions, security companies, the media and law enforcement agencies of "a significant increase in funds transfer fraud involving the exploitation of valid banking credentials belonging to small and medium sized businesses."




Editor's Note:  Again, exploitation is relative to how you conduct funds transfers.  Agreed, you cannot use a PC from which web browsing is possible, but you can utilize a device which doesn't use the web in the first place.



Analysis
The FS-ISAC warning calls into question the safety of online banking...and confirms that criminals are winning the cyber war against financial institution account holders....



Criminals raid these accounts for millions of dollars (no estimates are available for the total amount of money stolen, (but Gartner believes it could be very large) by planting trojans on user desktops to steal account credentials and transfer money to criminals' accounts. Especially problematic aspects of these incidents include:
  • Lack of disclosure by banks to shareholders and account holders, who must learn about these incidents from media reports

  • Criminals' practice of targeting business accounts, which are typically larger but enjoy less protection under the law than consumer accounts.

  • Lack of protection afforded by current antivirus and anti-malware software running on users' PCs, and users' failure to keep their protection software updated.

  • Criminals' ability to circumvent strong user authentication, which includes using dedicated one-time password tokens issued by the bank to business users.

  • The new level of sophistication in reconnaissance, asset acquisition and exploitation demonstrated by these attacks, raising the possibility that ex-intelligence, paramilitary and military personnel are working with traditional organized crime groups.

These multistage attacks do more harm to customers than large, well-publicized credit card breaches. When cards are stolen, regulations typically require reimbursement of customers for unauthorized charges. In money transfer attacks, business users are unlikely to recover the bulk of their stolen funds.








  • Don't rely solely on the strength of user authentication if the authentication is communicated through a PC browser.

Editor's Note:  Which is why HomeATM doesn't use the web browser for authentication, but instead utilizes the only PCI 2.x Certified PED in the world to instantaneously encrypt the authentication credentials and transmit the encrypted data using the Internet (not the web) as a conduit. Is it safer this way?  You can bank on it!











Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Posted by John B. Frank 0 comments

Sep 01, 2009 08:00 ET


BOKU Sets the Standard in Mobile Payments, Announces Arsenal of Online Games, Social Networking and Facebook Application Customers





Publishers Choose BOKU for High Conversion Rates, Sophisticated Technology and Coverage in 55 Countrie
s
SAN FRANCISCO, CA--(Marketwire - September 1, 2009) - BOKU, Inc., the standard for online mobile payments, today announced an extensive group of merchants and publishers who have selected BOKU for its convenient, bank-grade payment solution. Spanning the social and casual gaming, social networking and application spaces, these companies use the BOKU™ service to sell digital goods and services to their global customers. The service allows over 1.8 billion potential consumers to shop online and purchase virtual goods and digital content easily and securely using their mobile phone.



In addition, BOKU announces it is going live in the next week with its payment service in Indonesia, New Zealand, Slovenia and Taiwan, bringing the company's global reach to 55 countries.



Continuing on its recent success, BOKU has attracted an impressive set of customers, including Aeria Games, Badoo, fatfoogoo, Gambit, Games-Masters (Cabal Online), HitGrab (MouseHunt), Hive7 (Knighthood), Hi5, IceBreaker, IGG, Jambool, K2Networks/GamersFirst, Meez, Offerpal, PageFad (Premier Football), Playfish, Slide, Sometrics, Super Rewards, TheBroth (BarnBuddy), Three Rings, TrialPay and WeeWorld with more going live soon.



These publishers have chosen BOKU as a complete, online payments solution that offers analytics reporting, flexible billing and pricing, fraud and security management and greater revenue opportunities to partners in the USA and worldwide. Additionally, the company's global reach, leading technology platform, seasoned executive team and tier one investors set it apart from all other players. Today, the company has over 1000 customers that use BOKU as their mobile payments provider of choice.



"After switching to BOKU for mobile payments on Meez, we saw a dramatic increase in revenue," said John Cahill, CEO of Meez. "BOKU is leading the charge in alternative payments methods and we're extremely satisfied with their offerings -- not only to Meez as a company, but to our customers, as well."



"We chose to add BOKU for mobile payments for our 6 million gamers to pay for virtual goods," said Vu Hoang, co-founder of Aeria Games. "BOKU is an important and growing part of our business worldwide. They have great conversion rates and customers are quick to choose it as a payment method because of its ease and simplicity."



"Mobile payments for digital goods is one of the fastest growing segments of mobility," said J. Gerry Purdy, Ph.D., VP & Chief Analyst, Mobile & Wireless at Frost & Sullivan. "BOKU is clearly one of the early winners in this fast growing market with impressive customer wins and millions of transactions per month. We see billions of digital assets being purchase via mobile phone in the next few years."



"Since our launch this summer, BOKU has seen a tremendously positive response from the publisher community worldwide," said Ron Hirson, Co-founder and Senior Vice President of Product Marketing for BOKU. "In addition to seeing impressive revenue growth for our customers, BOKU itself has seen strong growth as it continues to set the new standard in mobile payments and further expand its international reach."



Watch a demonstration of how easy and safe it is to pay using BOKU.



About BOKU:



BOKU is creating the standard for online payments using your mobile phone, making it easy to pay for digital goods and social experiences across the web. With a strong focus on reliability and security, BOKU's goal is to bring bank-grade payments technology and mobile users together on the web, creating a trusted, viable and accessible market for consumers, publishers and carriers alike. Based in San Francisco with offices in Europe, Asia and Latin America, BOKU reaches over 1.8 billion consumers worldwide, and is funded by leading Silicon Valley entrepreneurs and venture capitalists Benchmark Capital, Index Ventures and Khosla Ventures. For more information, please visit boku.com.



BOKU and Pay by Mobile are registered trademarks or trademarks of BOKU, Inc., and/or its subsidiaries. All other brand names, product names, or trademarks belong to their respective holders. BOKU reserves the right to alter product offerings and specifications at any time without notice.

Posted by John B. Frank 0 comments

In the last two weeks, it should have become clear to everyone that Web Security is shot and online banking authentication, including One-Time Passwords (OTC's) and Transaction Authorization Numbers (TANs) needs to be.

40% more consumers are afraid to enter their personal details into web sites than last year, phishing has graduated to Trojans, no website is safe and we're still typing. Meanwhile, Hackers have created "real-time" Keylogging...meaning that even if we "create temporary numeric passwords that get changed each minute, the probelm is that the hacker/attacker now gets the same password immediately." Nice!

Below are links which review some of the posts that cover recent "uncoverings."
If he you have the time, read them and you'll be as convinced as I am that we need to stop typing and start swiping.


Older to Newer: Recent PIN Payments News posts Regarding Web and Online Banking Insecurity


Web Insecurity Part Deaux (Don't...Trust It)

MasterCard vs. Visa: Dueling Compliance Philosphies

Malware Aimed at Stealing Bank Log-In Credentials Growing

ONO! Huge Security Hole on the Web

Bi-Annual Web Hacking Report Released by Breach.com

Credit Card Scam Raises New Web Security Fears

What Causes Financial Fraud? (It's the Stupid Typing!)

Card Fraud Expected to Increase in US...Yet We're Still Typing and Hackers are Still Swiping!

HomeATM's Weapon of "Phish Destruction"...

Did You See the HomeATM Finovate Startup '09 Live Demo?

Attempted Card Not Present Fraud in China up 60%

Experts: More Heartland Style Breaches Expected: This is Probably Just the Start!

Hacker Costs Keep Growing

Hackers Exploit Evolving Web

The HomeATM Solution

Real Time Keylogging Makes OTP Log-In Obsolete (If you Type it...They will Come!)

Online Banking Fraud Worse Than We Think (and we think it's BAD!)

Browsers are to Hacking what Fuel is to Race Cars

As Predicted, It's Getting Worse...Not Better!

Skimming Prevention: Best Practices for Merchantsl

Top 11 eCommerce Paradigm Shifters Put HomeATM in Gear

IBM: Unprecedented State of Web Insecurity - No Such Thing as Safe Browsing

Online Banking Insecure...Only 1 Bank Rated Excellent

FDIC: Online Banking Flawed

HomeATM Provides the "Inevitable" Solution Now

Not the "Type" of Two Factor Authentication we Need...





Posted by John B. Frank 0 comments

From the "wait a minute, are you sure that's safe?" department: 



It took Japanese researchers only 60 seconds but it appears as if  the replacement to the extremely vulnerable WEP needs replacing. 



The WPA encryption system used for wireless security can hacked in about 60 seconds.  That's scary since the WPA protocol and related TKIP were created due to weaknesses discovered in Wired Equivalent Privacy (WEP).



According to CBR, "The security attack they have formulated for the Wi-Fi Protected Access or WPA protocol is similar to one known as the Beck-Tews attack which appeared last year as a means of recovering plain text from an encrypted short packet, and from there falsifying it.  That took anything up to 15 minutes. But with this latest message falsification attack, which is good for pretty much any WPA implementation, the execution time is cut to about one minute in the best case."



Can't say I'm surprised...the writing was on the wall...(see previous posts on wireless insecurity below) Remember, our boy Albert Gonzalez,.a.k.a. "SoupNazi" got his start thanks to WEP by Wardriving. 





PIN Debit Payments Blog: Wireless Security Does Not Have Any...

Mar 15, 2009


The group accused of stealing the TJX data was believed to have hacked into several stores' weakly encrypted wireless
networks. Last year, supermarket company Hannaford Bros. reported a data breach, saying customer accounts at stores in ...
May 14, 2009
AirTight Networks published a study of wireless access points and found that the majority still use WEP and the WEP cracking time is less than five minutes. Interesting study. The URL to the PDF is at the end of this post. ...
Aug 17, 2009
DENVER - August 17, 2009 - First Data, a global leader in electronic commerce and payment processing services, announced today that it is launching the FD400, the first low-cost, battery-powered, wireless point-of-sale terminal for
Jul 15, 2009
Considering today's announcement that PCI is publishing "wireless" security guidelines, I don't see any reason why the council wouldn't be 100% behind putting together a Web Special Interest Group (SIG) and begin this much needed ...
 
Aug 19, 2008
Despite serving as an informant, the Justice Department claims, Gonzalez also began "wardriving" in the areas around US Highway 1 in Miami, according to this month's indictments. The term refers to the tactic of cruising in a vehicle 



PIN Debit Payments Blog: Wireless Identity Theft - More on Hackers 11

24 Nov 2008 


In an article published on IBLS (Internet Business Law Services) the author talks about wireless hacking (See WarDriving 101), Hackers 11 and possible changes in laws relating to cybercriminal behavior. ...




Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Posted by John B. Frank 0 comments

Payments Industry News Blog

Search the PIN Debit Blog by Subject

Kapersky Calls for Mass Adoption of Card Readers

Kapersky Calls for Mass Adoption of Card Readers